Temps de lecture : 6 minutes

For several weeks now, French society has been experiencing episodes of violence amidst legitimate demands. Our Life Project invites us to bear witness to hope (no. 20), to be peacemakers and to seek ‘concrete and personal forms of fraternity’. It is therefore worth reflecting on public peace and how to safeguard it. It was General (2S) Jean-Régis Véchambre 1 who assists us in this endeavour. His comments do not reflect the views of the institution to which he belonged.

The images shown to us by the media paint a murky picture of the police. What thoughts does this inspire in you?

It should be remembered that the maintenance of public order, as defined by the national public order framework, “has as its primary aim to enable the exercise of individual and collective freedoms, whilst regulating them. It therefore consists, first and foremost, of preventive measures. This maintenance of public order consists, in fact, of preventing, containing and reducing – through the controlled use of law enforcement – disturbances arising from organised or spontaneous actions, whether hostile or benevolent, violent or peaceful, of a protest or celebratory nature, taking place on public roads or in public places.

Law enforcement operations aim to restore public order

When all or part of the assembled crowd commits acts that undermine public order, law enforcement operations aim to restore public order, in particular through measures to protect people and property, as well as by apprehending offenders’. Whilst the preventive aspect takes precedence, I believe it would be useful to move from the concept of ‘maintaining order/restoring order’ to that of ‘protecting public peace and freedom of expression’.

Protecting public peace and freedom of expression

This concept gives true meaning to the mission; it makes it compatible with the complexity of situations or phenomena (traditional street or venue-based demonstrations, traditional demonstrations intertwined with violent protests, urban violence, violence in contested areas, protest-related violence during meetings or gatherings, and long-term phenomena of opposition to democracy). It also has the advantage of repositioning, as is appropriate, public order and the challenge of maintaining it, concepts that are much broader and which citizens today struggle to grasp. Public order encompasses public safety, public tranquillity, public health, public morality (within very specific limits) and respect for human dignity.

These same images show situations of tension between law enforcement and demonstrators. How can we properly understand the interactions between these two parties?

Two preliminary semantic observations:

– Firstly, I do not like the term ‘law enforcement’. What ‘law’ exactly? It is actually more accurate to refer to ‘public security forces’.
– Secondly, the word ‘protagonist’, in this specific context, will be understood to refer to people in conflict. Whilst – and I’ll come to this – this may describe the stance of violent demonstrators or protesters, the public security forces do not see themselves as a party to a conflict. Rather, they are stakeholders, whether voluntary or involuntary.
Finally, there are not two but four stakeholders, some of whom may themselves be diverse, convergent or even opposed. Schematically, in a physical sense, we can consider four forces: the initial force, the acting force, the targeted force and the supervising force.

Four forces: the initial, the acting, the targeted and the supervising

The initial force(s) consist of demonstrators, whether organised or unorganised, sometimes accompanied by processions of opponents whom it will be necessary to prevent from meeting by interposing oneself; these may be joined by violent groups with various motivations—whether convergent or independent—who often seek to infiltrate the processions. Next comes the active force, the police with its various components. Then there are the forces targeted by the initial forces, including the police targeted by violent groups, but also shops and banks representing capitalism or simply as targets for looting, government ministries, and locations or areas to be seized or held… Finally, there are the supporting forces, comprising everyone affected by the consequences of the protest (loss of customers, blockades endured…) who suffer but may also rebel against the protesters, for lack of protection. We always forget that freedom, as enshrined in the constitution, ends where that of others begins. Of the 11 deaths during the ‘Yellow Vests’ crisis, 10 were the result of altercations or accidents between the initial force and the surrounding force, in the absence of the intervening force whose intervention would have been beneficial.

The police and its officers must not regard themselves as a party to a conflict,

At demonstrations, slogans or acronyms such as ‘fascists’, ‘ACAB’ (standing for ‘All cops are bastards’), ‘the police kill’, or even ‘barbarians’ are shouted at the police. They appear to designate a specific enemy to be targeted, struck and attacked – and, what is more, a complete reversal of roles, an enemy of public order.

The police and their officers should not regard themselves as a party to a conflict or a confrontation, even – and especially – when attempts are made to draw them into it. It is not because organisations and citizens decide to break the social contract by resorting to violence that the police should, in turn, give in to it. From this perspective, the term ‘adversary’, still used in doctrine to refer to demonstrators, creates confusion.

The police cannot have an adversary; on the contrary, they must facilitate and support the exercise of public expression and constantly strive to restore calm. Nor must they do anything that could be perceived as instigating a confrontation. Escalation cannot and must not be their doing.

The terms regularly mentioned in legal doctrine are ‘self-sacrifice’, meaning self-forgetfulness, and ‘long-suffering’, which implies accepting and enduring suffering. This is difficult in an individualistic society where the dominant philosophy is hedonism, characterised by the pursuit of personal pleasure and the rejection of suffering – in other words, the exact opposite.

To stop viewing demonstrators as adversaries, however, requires us to describe them for what they are by characterising their behaviour. This ranges from peaceful demonstrators to those carrying out actions that remain within the bounds of acceptable disorder, and then to rioters or violent protesters who have crossed over into unacceptable disorder and have therefore stepped outside the framework of the demonstration, whilst remaining entirely neutral, both towards them and with regard to the cause motivating their actions.

What Christian perspectives can we bring to this mission of safeguarding public peace and freedom of expression?

The very essence of public peace, which banishes violence, vengeance, hatred… and everything else enshrined in the law, in the image of the Ten Commandments. We must not forget that a police officer is obliged to come to the aid of others even at the risk of his own life. This mission, which may extend to the sacrifice of one’s life (for military personnel), the devotion to the mission, the service of peace, through self-giving and self-forgetfulness, resonates strongly with the definition of Christian love.

Leo XIV

Pope Leo XIV, when he visited France in September 2026, recalled that the dignity inherent in every human being is reflected in [o]ur national motto. He also said, “that liberty, equality and fraternity are not merely words engraved on the pediments of [o]ur public buildings, but refer to universal ethical imperatives which also find in the Gospel message an inexhaustible source of inspiration and fulfilment. ’ In this we find an echo of the mission carried out, in particular, by the police force.

The police force serves the common good

Likewise, in the concept of the police force, which serves the common good, we can find an echo of the virtue of courage. This consists in exercising the strength to control oneself, to be a force for peace rather than confrontation, whilst strictly observing the established limits (no anger, no insults…). I have chosen to be a member of the police force, not of public violence. This is what is known as moral strength.

—————–

1.General (2S) Jean-Régis Véchambre, President of the National Society for the History and Heritage of the Gendarmerie – Society of Friends of the Gendarmerie Museum (SAMG), former Inspector-General of the Armed Forces – Gendarmerie. He was also Deputy Director for Defence and Public Order at the Gendarmerie Directorate and was a member of the panel of experts for the National Law and Order Plan (SNMO)

2. André Lalande, Violence, Technical and Critical Vocabulary of Philosophy, Paris, Presses universitaires de France, 1972 [2020], E, p. 1210.</p2